Being No One by Thomas Metzinger (or his much briefer, less technical summary The Ego Tunnel).Chapter II - The Biological foundations of personal identity — DeSoto
Is there a line or sort of bag of which we can say that "inside" that line or interface is "me" and "outside" is the environment or some other person? By what right do we make these distinctions?
It is clear (though usually ignored) that the language of any answer to that question is not, in the end, a language of space or time. "Inside" and "outside" are not appropriate metaphors for inclusion and exclusion when we are speaking of the self.
The mind contains no things, no pigs, no people, no midwife toad s , or what have you , only ideas (ie, news of difference), in-formation about "things" in quotes, always in quotes. Similarly, the mind contains no time and no space, only ideas of "time" and "space." It follows that the boundaries of the individual , if real at all , will be, not spatial boundaries, but something more like the sacks that represent sets in set theoretical diagrams or the bubbles that come out of the mouths of the characters in comic strips.
My daughter, now aged ten, had her birthday last week. The tenth birthday is an important one because it represents a breakthrough into two-digit numbers. She remarked, half serious and half in jest, that she did not "feel any different. "
The boundary between the ninth year and the tenth year was not real in the sense of being or representing a change in feeling. But one could perhaps make Venn diagrams or bubbles to classify propositions about various ages.
In addition, I want to focus on that genus of receipt of information (or call it learning) which is learning about the "self" in a way that may result in some "change" in the "self." Especially, I will look at changes in the boundaries of the self, perhaps at the discovery that there are boundaries or perhaps no center. And so on. — Ch.5.
Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.