A state of affairs (presumably conditional on some standard or value) — Andrew M
I would prefer not to continue this conversation, thanks. — Snakes Alive
We can judge that it is raining, but this does not mean that that it is raining is not a judgment. — Snakes Alive
My question is, why does the fact that we only find judgments about whether something is good, tell us anything about whether things are only good to some S? — Snakes Alive
Great. So we agree this is a bad argument. — Snakes Alive
If judgment that something is P is only found in an individual is not[/o] a reason for believing that something can be P only to some S, say in the case of whether it's raining, then it equally cannot be a reason for believing this in the case of goodness. — Snakes Alive
So what's the evidence that good is always good to some S? — Snakes Alive
Says who? — Snakes Alive
Is it possible to approve of something that's not good? Yes — Snakes Alive
Moral judgements, like all judgements, are true, or they are false. This follows from their predicate-subject form. — Banno
If it can be proven logically that it is possible for time to pass without any changes occurring, — Metaphysician Undercover
This is most to the fore when what you want is not what you know you ought do. — Banno
