• frank
    16k
    It's a research based fact that people with first names that sound "black" (like Lashika, for instance) are much less likely to be called in for interviews than people with old English sounding names (like Frank).

    Would you say that's a sign of systemic racism? I'm asking.
  • NOS4A2
    9.3k


    The essential problem centers around acquiring and maintaining power or advantage. People don't discriminate against those with superficial differences for no reason. In order to correct the unfair practices, you need to address whatever established taxonomy has been used. Naturally, it will be an uphill battle because people generally hate giving up an advantage.

    I can agree with that. I just think the very first step to correcting them should be to refuse using those taxonomies. They automatically lead to the hastiest of generalizations, unable to account for the disparities between individuals who may or may not be a part of those groups.
  • frank
    16k
    I'm just curious: you're not in the US, so is there a minority in your country that suffers from discrimination?
  • praxis
    6.6k
    I just think the very first step to correcting them should be to refuse using those taxonomies. They automatically lead to the hastiest of generalizationsNOS4A2

    One of the first steps, in my opinion, would be to look at these 'hasty generalizations' that you mention. Look at what's behind the taxonomies.

    It's a research based fact that people with first names that sound "black" (like Lashika, for instance) are much less likely to be called in for interviews than people with old English sounding names (like Frank).

    Would you say that's a sign of systemic racism?
    frank

    No.
  • frank
    16k

    No.
    praxis
    :up:

    When we talk about systemic racism are we mainly talking about demographics?

    For instance, if Latinos are statistically poorer than blacks, would we see that as a sign of more potent racism for Latinos vs blacks?

    Or are there upstream facts that we use to make our assessments?
  • creativesoul
    12k
    Race-ism (the belief in race)...NOS4A2

    Bullshit.

    Belief in race does not equate to devaluing one because of their race. The former is necessary for the latter, but not all belief in race includes devaluing one because of race. The former is not what we are referring to by "racism". Rather, it's the latter.

    You're abusing language here.

    To defeat racism is to value people equally regardless of their race.
  • creativesoul
    12k
    Good. Now what do you think is keeping the disparities in play?

    Mostly the way you frame them. If you view it through the lens of race, racial disparities necessarily arise.
    NOS4A2

    If you do not include race in the discussion, then racial disparities aren't able to be identified!

    :brow:

    Hence, one can claim color-blindness as a means to intentionally not address the problems.
  • praxis
    6.6k
    Or are there upstream facts that we use to make our assessments?frank

    Yes.
  • frank
    16k
    Yes.praxis

    Like what?
  • Banno
    25.3k
    The overwhelming problem in this thread is the failure to distinguish race from ethnicity.

    Sort that one out, folks.
  • praxis
    6.6k


    There are examples in housing, loan practices, the judicial system, health and environment. None of them will be very overt, in this day and age. Do you need convincing or what? It seems like many of those who don't want to see it can't see it. Well, I don't want to see it but the evidence is there.
  • frank
    16k

    I could go on and on, dividing up black perspectives into categories like the Spike Lee attitude, the Bill Cosby viewpoint, etc. etc. etc.

    I don't join teams because it's not a football game to me. What I'll note is that though many fans of systemic racism have spoken in this thread, none of them seem to be able to give a specific example of it or even explain what the hell it's actually supposed to be.

    I thought you might correct that. And you better be friendly to me or I'll bombard your inbox with youtube videos about American expressionism.
  • praxis
    6.6k


    It’s not a game to you but you won’t even exert the marginal effort it would take to look this shit up yourself. :chin:
  • NOS4A2
    9.3k


    Where I live are racial disparities, yes, and a legacy of racism and racial policies.
  • frank
    16k
    It’s not a game to you but you won’t even exert the marginal effort it would take to look this shit up yourself. :chin:praxis

    That's it. Say hello to Jackson Pollack.
  • frank
    16k
    Where I live are racial disparities, yes, and a legacy of racism and racial policies.NOS4A2

    Are racial policies still in place?
  • NOS4A2
    9.3k


    Bullshit.

    Belief in race does not equate to devaluing one because of their race. The former is necessary for the latter, but not all belief in race includes devaluing one because of race. The former is not what we are referring to by "racism". Rather, it's the latter.

    You're abusing language here.

    To defeat racism is to value people equally regardless of their race.

    I never said the belief in race equates to devaluing one because of her race. What I’m trying to say is that the belief that the species can be divided into such subgroups, it’s assumptions, the race-thinking, provides the foundation for all racist discriminations and hatred. It’s a false, a superstitious and dangerous taxonomy. To see it continue to metastasize in government, corporate, and cultural institutions should be cause for grave concern.
  • NOS4A2
    9.3k


    Racial policies still exist but in the form of affirmative action.
  • creativesoul
    12k
    I never said the belief in race equates to devaluing one because of her race.NOS4A2

    Right!

    You said belief in race is racism. It's not!

    Racism is devaluing someone based upon race. Belief in race is not racism.
  • NOS4A2
    9.3k


    If you do not include race in the discussion, then racial disparities aren't able to be identified!

    :brow:

    Hence, one can claim color-blindness as a means to intentionally not address the problems.

    We’re talking about race. At no point do I deny or ignore the legacy of racism.
  • frank
    16k
    Racial policies still exist but in the form of affirmative action.NOS4A2

    Affirmative Action is an American thing, sparky. Good try, though. :kiss:
  • creativesoul
    12k
    We’re talking about race. At no point do I deny or ignore the legacy of racism.NOS4A2

    Good. Assuming you - like other reasonable considerate people - want to work on correcting racism, you must realize that it cannot be corrected by denying race.
  • NOS4A2
    9.3k


    Right!

    You said belief in race is racism. It's not!

    Racism is devaluing someone based upon race. Belief in race is not racism.

    And next you’ll appeal to the dictionary.
  • creativesoul
    12k


    Appeal to the dictionary? For what. Belief in race is not racism. It's necessary for racism, but not sufficient.
  • DingoJones
    2.8k
    And next you’ll appeal to the dictionary.NOS4A2

    You dont buy that definition of racism? How do you define it?
  • NOS4A2
    9.3k


    Nice try. They go under different names elsewhere.
  • frank
    16k
    They go under different names elsewhere.NOS4A2

    You mean for college admissions? Affirmative action was much bigger than that. So no, it's not the same thing.
  • NOS4A2
    9.3k


    Appeal to the dictionary? For what. Belief in race is not racism. It's necessary for racism, but not sufficient.

    Race-ism. It’s quite simple. The suffix ‘ism’ is attached to the root word ‘race’.
  • NOS4A2
    9.3k


    You mean for college admissions? Affirmative action was much bigger than that. So no, it's not the same thing.

    About one quarter of nations across the world use some form of affirmative action for student admissions into higher education.

    https://ejournals.bc.edu/index.php/ihe/article/download/5672/5065/
  • creativesoul
    12k


    Don't be such a dumb fuck! There is a long history of what racism is, of how the word is used, of what it refers to, of what it picks out to the exclusion of all else....

    It does not pick out belief in race.
bold
italic
underline
strike
code
quote
ulist
image
url
mention
reveal
youtube
tweet
Add a Comment