• Hello Human
    195
    The uncaused cause of the universe is a subject of interest to the philosophy of religion and metaphysics. However, I have not yet encountered a satisfying set of necessary conditions for something to be the so-called "uncaused cause".

    The definition that I have encountered the most is that it must have existed from eternity until at the beginning of the universe or after, however I take issue with this definition. That is, it does not not rule out the possibility of an infinite causal chain. An infinite causal chain must, by definition, exist since eternity, as every time you ask what is the cause of one event you'd go back further in time, because a cause must happen before its effects, and in order for it to be infinite, it must have no end, therefore an infinite causal chain is a possible candidate for an uncaused first cause.

    So, what do you think ? What is necessary for something to be the "uncaused first cause" ? Do you think we should accept an infinite causal chain as a candidate, which would be devastating to Aquinas' argument from causation ?
  • Gregory
    4.6k


    Aquinas said that an essential infinite past is impossible without God because God alone makes it essential, otherwise it is accidental and dependent on itself. He didn't understand physics however! If you have an infinite dominoes series than saying each fall of a dominoes is caused by the previous doesn't explain how the series works, but if you have gravity in the equation the infinite series is self consistent. Imagine the universe as an infinite slide causing water to slide it forever in the past and future. In this case we don't have a dominoes series where there is no engine of causality. We have gravity working it's magic and all that is required is a properly modelled universe
  • TheMadFool
    13.8k
    Order is a phase in chaos. Causation is an aspect of order. In chaos there is no order, no causation. Ergo, causation is an illusion, a temporary state of order, in what is actually chaos.

    Your question about an uncaused cause is moot! There is no causation!

    By the way, what about us, yes, us humans? Did you forget free will?
bold
italic
underline
strike
code
quote
ulist
image
url
mention
reveal
youtube
tweet
Add a Comment

Welcome to The Philosophy Forum!

Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.