• thewonder
    1.4k
    I have decided to post an experimental poem here for review so as to discover what anyone else thinks about it. I begins and ends as poetry, but makes a lengthy departure into Film Theory in the middle. I am curious as to what anyone thinks about either my ruminations or the poem as a whole. Here it is:

    "Band of Outsiders" by Jaska Xaver

    In D minor

    There is a copy of Band of Outsiders that I checked out from a local record store
    and lost
    having been imbued with the memory
    of falling in love
    with the world that I had projected upon her
    awake at 4 A.M.
    and watching a video that someone had created
    for The Brian Jonestown Massacre’s “The Devil May Care (Mom and Dad Don’t)”
    for the seventh time
    and discovering the emerald green glow on the horizon
    in the cool tranquility before dawn

    I had once thought that the sun cast
    bright golden carmine
    across the snow covered plains
    in the waking hours of a day gone by
    in an old house that I’ve never been to
    where you were cast in a film about snipers
    and I had forgotten to
    make the coffee for the crew
    and scout the next location

    They say that it is quite common for people to remember events that never took place.
    As if even memory was mediated by images within what Guy Debord called “The Spectacle”.
    Jean Luc Godard, whom the Situationist International neither disavowed or claimed as one of their own, is famous for having allegedly stated that “Cinema is truth twenty-four frames per second”.
    As it appears in The Little Soldier, his meditation upon The Algerian War of Independence, the quote actually reads “Photography is truth and cinema is truth 24 times a second.”
    A photograph is a historical record that serves as a synecdoche for an event that occurs as a totality.
    Their existence emphatically proves, once and for all, that subjectivity can only be transcended through the cultivation of collective memory.
    I had once imagined that I had been told a story about a newspaper article on the riots against the Serbian population that occurred following the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand.
    He told me that, in spite of that the image of the destroyed carriage was a painful reminder of the intransigent ethnic strife that had incited the war, he left article up, nailed to his wall, for years later.
    He said that he had done so because he identified with one the people who had been captured by the photographer.
    He, then, moved his finger across the scene so as to accentuate the damage, and said,
    “I guess that I left that article up for all of these years because I thought that that was what had become of this world...”
    He, then, pointed to a man in the background of the image and said,
    “…and that’s me running away.”
    Regardless as to what is actually written in that article, my relationship to that event is mediated by an encounter that I only imagined during an odd repose from a fit of mania that I had experienced while compulsively accumulating information from Wikipedia.
    History is not a scientific record.
    It is also comprised of the evanescent respite from the analysis of information that inspires the creation of works of art.
    There is, perhaps, something all too Vitalist, even solipsistic, or, dare I say, “Fascist”, to that sentiment, though.
    It’s not that I think that Jean Luc Godard was mistaken, photography is truth and cinema, at its most basic level, is a succession of photographs; it’s just that I think that he, perhaps, had not considered the implications of that truth can be created as a mediator for a person’s subjective relationship to collective memory.
    Lawrence Olivier’s Hamlet is “truth”, Ivan’s Childhood is “truth”, Maya Deren’s At Land is “truth”, the archival footage utilized in documentaries on the Holocaust is “truth”, and The Triumph of the Will is “truth”.
    Jean Baudrillad is famous for having cited Ecclesiastes as stating that, “The simulacrum is never that which conceals the truth—it is the truth which conceals that there is none. The simulacrum is true.”
    Cinema is as much of a simulation of an event as it is a record of an event in its own right.
    When people create a film, they actually attempt to participate in the creation of memory,
    and fail, I might add,
    as, like any work of art,
    what there is left upon the reel never quite appears as its author had imagined
    and what a person feels when they see the film projected always somehow differs from every other person in the theater.

    I bring all of this up because
    I now wonder
    what it will be like
    for a person to discover
    an unreturned copy of Band of Outsiders
    perhaps, for the first time
    there as a record
    of the love I’ve never known
    or the life they’ve just begun

    You can listen to my recording of the poem here.
  • Jack Cummins
    5.1k

    I am impressed by your poem. Also, I am interested that you have come across 'A Band of Outsiders' because not many people I know follow such music. I really like the Brian Johnson Massacre.
  • thewonder
    1.4k

    Thank you! I'm honestly probably a better poet than I am a philosopher. Band of Outsiders is one of my favorite films. In passing conversation, I often cite it as such, as not many people have seen Chris Maker's Sans Soleil.

    Though I think the poem could be better without revealing too much about what had inspired it, the anecdote which it opens with is actually true. This is the video that I had watched.

    The Brian Jonestown Massacre is an incredible band. Though, as I live in a city where heroin addiction is a serious plight and have lost a few friends to it, I am not so inclined to tacitly support the revolution, if you will, that they endorsed as I was at a young age after having seen the film, Dig, I have listened to almost all of their albums and do think that Anton Newcombe, despite the many absurdities of his person, ought to be lauded as a creative genius.
  • Jack Cummins
    5.1k

    Actually, we were talking at cross purposes because I wasn't referring to the film but a really obscure band called The Band of Outsiders. I have hardly watched any films at all but I constantly experiment with all the alternative genres of music, ranging from punk, goth, psyche rock etc.
  • thewonder
    1.4k

    I'd bet that they take their name from the film. I'll have to check them out.
bold
italic
underline
strike
code
quote
ulist
image
url
mention
reveal
youtube
tweet
Add a Comment

Welcome to The Philosophy Forum!

Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.