• baker
    5.6k
    This has come up in another discussion about the pandemic and the measures against it taken by governments:

    Also, asking whether those worst affected by measures of they are in favour of them is rather dishonest. Such measures are statistical, taken for the sake of the whole population in order to minimise, not simply eradicate, harm.Kenosha Kid

    A similar situation occurs whenever there's a clash between the individual and larger organization (such as the government or the medical system).

    The larger organization operates in big numbers.
    From its perspective, it's acceptable if a medical treatment has serious side-effects for a certain % of the population.
    From its perspective, it's acceptable if a governmental measure during the pandemic leads to job loss for a certain % of the population.

    For the larger organization, some losses are acceptable. It goes further: it expects that those who are that loss -- those who end up losing jobs in a pandemic because the government doesn't allow their industry to operate, or those who end up with permanent negative effects of a medical treatment -- nevertheless continue to trust the larger organization as if all was well.

    So if you -- yes, you -- end up being the unfortunate one who lost their job because of the measures; if you end up being the one permanently paralyzed by the vaccine:

    How do you still trust the government, the medical system?

    How do you make sense of the damage that you yourself suffer, presumably for the wellbeing of others?

    The government and the medical system expect you to view yourself as an expendable cog in the system. As such, how do you still trust them?
  • Joshs
    5.2k
    The government and the medical system expect you to view yourself as an expendable cog in the system. As such, how do you still trust them?baker

    First talk to your neighbors in your local
    community. Most likely the government and the medical system are making the choices you mention with the support of a substantial segment of the people around you ( unless you live in a conservative part of the country, which is why you probably posted this).
    People have attacked government for requiring mask wearing, but in my city, government enforcement of masks pales in comparison to peer pressure from my neighbors. My friend calls it ‘mask shaming’. I wouldn’t get two blocks without someone pointing to my face motioning me to mask up.
bold
italic
underline
strike
code
quote
ulist
image
url
mention
reveal
youtube
tweet
Add a Comment

Welcome to The Philosophy Forum!

Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.